Results 1 to 24 of 24

Thread: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

  1. #1
    remicks's Avatar
    remicks is online now Double Platinum Record [Level 9]
    Joined
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Central Coast California
    Posts
    5,366

    When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    ******

    Three come to mind :


    Patrick Adams and Eddie Kendricks :




    Van McCoy and Aretha Franklin:




    TSOP and The Jacksons:





    Others ????



    ******
    Baby, take me
    high upon a hillside

    high up where the stallion
    meets the sun



  2. #2
    SandraDee's Avatar
    SandraDee is offline Double Platinum Record [Level 9]
    Joined
    Mar 2002
    Location
    Manchester, UK
    Posts
    5,357

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    I found the George Mcrae LP produced by Gregg Diamond disappointing. The Phyllis Hyman material that Narada Michael Walden produced was naff too (& I love both of them so much). The Carol Douglas LP that Greg Carmichael & Fitch/Cross shared production credits on (Come Into My Life) was a let down for me too. I have to say that I'm a huge Nile Rodgers fan generally but his 80s collaborations with Grace Jones, David Bowie & Madonna all left me rather cold.
    ...ya gotta beat the street......

  3. #3
    Joined
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Dallas, TX
    Posts
    191

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Giorgio Moroder:

    France Joli "Attitude" LP
    Janet Jackson "Dream Street" LP

  4. #4
    remicks's Avatar
    remicks is online now Double Platinum Record [Level 9]
    Joined
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Central Coast California
    Posts
    5,366

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    *****

    Good ones !
    :icon_biggrin:

    Here's another :

    CHIC and BLONDIE:






    ******
    Baby, take me
    high upon a hillside

    high up where the stallion
    meets the sun



  5. #5
    Joined
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Honolulu
    Posts
    210

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    As well as duds, such collaborations can produce gems:

    Chic producing Diana Ross: 'Upside Down' and 'I'm Coming Out'

    Boogie down

  6. #6
    Joined
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Dallas, TX
    Posts
    191

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    I don't know if Pete Bellotte would qualify as a "Giant" without Giorgio but if so:

    Pete Bellotte:

    Melba Moore "Burn" LP
    Elton John "Victim of Love" LP

  7. #7
    remicks's Avatar
    remicks is online now Double Platinum Record [Level 9]
    Joined
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Central Coast California
    Posts
    5,366

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Quote Originally Written by The Boogie Doctor View Post
    As well as duds, such collaborations can produce gems:

    Chic producing Diana Ross: 'Upside Down' and 'I'm Coming Out'

    Good point!!! :icon_biggrin: :icon_mrgreen: :icon_biggrin:


    *****
    Baby, take me
    high upon a hillside

    high up where the stallion
    meets the sun



  8. #8
    Dansez! is offline Advance Promo Copy [Level 3]
    Joined
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Bay Area
    Posts
    50

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Quote Originally Written by Boogie Child View Post
    I don't know if Pete Bellotte would qualify as a "Giant" without Giorgio but if so:

    Pete Bellotte:

    Melba Moore "Burn" LP
    Elton John "Victim of Love" LP
    Although it has a much harder sound than most Melba Moore albums, I like this album a lot. In fact, I like every song on it.

  9. #9
    Joined
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Dallas, TX
    Posts
    191

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    In retrospect, I remember seeing Melba Moore sing "Miss Thing" on the Bea Arthur TV special around 1980, and it was quite good.

  10. #10
    Joined
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Honolulu
    Posts
    210

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    The Diana Ross' LP produced by Chic had some compelling songs on it, yet the process through which some of those songs were constructed was occasionally fraught with tension. For instance, the initial recorded version of 'Upside Down' produced by Edwards and Rodgers was strongly oriented toward the dancefloor and thus duly possessed a pronounced rhythm section. However, after a close appraisal Ross and her engineers decided to remix the song, deeming it too 'bass heavy,' the comment obviously implying that Ross' vocals were submerged in the mix and not leaping out at the listener as she desired. Rodgers and Edwards gave their consent to the reconstruction, yet subsequently vowed never to work with Ross again. The brothers were devotees of the groove and may be worship them for that committment.

  11. #11
    Joined
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Toronto, Canada
    Posts
    430

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    re: Melba Moore "Burn".

    Yeah, other than Miss Thing and the subtle Night People, this LP has very few strong cuts. They all feel washed out and lifeless-especially "Hot And Tasty".

    And why is that Melba sounds so un-Melba here?
    "I come from a world where there's nothing you can live for, except when day turns into night, I'm a star in neon lights..."

  12. #12
    Joined
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Vancouver BC Canada
    Posts
    862

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Quote Originally Written by FrontPage22 View Post
    re: Melba Moore "Burn".

    Yeah, other than Miss Thing and the subtle Night People, this LP has very few strong cuts. They all feel washed out and lifeless-especially "Hot And Tasty". And why is that Melba sounds so un-Melba here?
    I have this album and I'll have to give it a relisten one day. I know its not one of my fave Melba albums.

    Quote Originally Written by Boogie Child
    Elton John "Victim of Love" LP
    I know this wasn't one of Elton's big selling albums as I think this was recorded in the period referred to as his slump, but I love the entire side two mix.

  13. #13
    Joined
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Dallas, TX
    Posts
    191

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    What about the Human League and Jimmy Jam/Terry Lewis? I was underwhelmed with this collaboration.

  14. #14
    Joined
    Aug 2004
    Location
    Seattle, WA - USA
    Posts
    639

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Quote Originally Written by Boogie Child View Post
    Giorgio Moroder:

    France Joli "Attitude" LP
    And then Witch Of Love with George Duke.

    : (

    I thought the most disappointing collaboration was Nile Rodgers producing Nile Rodgers (did he run out of ideas for his solo work?)
    "Because there's music in the air."

  15. #15
    remicks's Avatar
    remicks is online now Double Platinum Record [Level 9]
    Joined
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Central Coast California
    Posts
    5,366

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    *****

    Alec Costandinos & Tina Turner :






    *****
    Baby, take me
    high upon a hillside

    high up where the stallion
    meets the sun



  16. #16
    Joined
    Jun 2005
    Location
    Richmond, VA
    Posts
    103

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    As I mentioned on the Ike and Tina Turner Goes Disco thread, "Love Explosion" was an attempt to cash in on the craze but her voice was not suited for it. It was also a transitional period when she was black listed after leaving Ike and abandoning a tour they were on and legally liable for the lost revenue... she needed any kind of work she could get to pay it off with anyone who would give her a second chance.

    The album cover is also one of the most unflattering pictures of Tina I've seen... makes her look like she is anemic and strung out.

    Eric

  17. #17
    Joined
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Fort Lauderdale, FL
    Posts
    1,403

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Quote Originally Written by FranceJoliFan View Post
    And then Witch Of Love with George Duke. :(
    I dunno... Her remake of Katia's "Party Lights" did pretty well for me. Of course, I had to use the DiscoNet extended edit, as there was no 12" mix. But it's an excellent restructuring of one of my favorite France Joli tracks.

    And to quote KDavid13's write-up on the LP, on the Disco-Discography side of DiscoMusic.com; "PARTY LIGHTS also won the "Most outstanding performance award" at the World Popular Song Festival in Tokyo (1984)"
    "MUSIC IS AN EMOTION, SEARCHING FOR IT'S VOICE"

    ...come with me, "BACK TO MUSIC", on DISCOTERIA
    http://www.live365.com/stations/cdnbob2

  18. #18
    remicks's Avatar
    remicks is online now Double Platinum Record [Level 9]
    Joined
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Central Coast California
    Posts
    5,366

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Quote Originally Written by Huffstutler View Post
    As I mentioned on the Ike and Tina Turner Goes Disco thread, "Love Explosion" was an attempt to cash in on the craze but her voice was not suited for it. It was also a transitional period when she was black listed after leaving Ike and abandoning a tour they were on and legally liable for the lost revenue... she needed any kind of work she could get to pay it off with anyone who would give her a second chance.

    The album cover is also one of the most unflattering pictures of Tina I've seen... makes her look like she is anemic and strung out.

    Eric
    OK that explains it for Tina ..... now what's Alec's excuse!!

    When you think about it, isn't this one of the most unlikely pairings imaginable???
    I wonder how in the world it ever came to be ?????

    *****
    Baby, take me
    high upon a hillside

    high up where the stallion
    meets the sun



  19. #19
    Joined
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Fort Lauderdale, FL
    Posts
    1,403

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Quote Originally Written by remicks View Post
    OK, that explains it for Tina. Now, what's Alec's excuse?
    When you think about it, isn't this one of the most unlikely pairings imaginable? I wonder how in the world it ever came to be?
    Probably the way most studio pairings tend to occur...

    Alec was on top as a Producer (or at least, had been, for a couple years) and Tina's label wanted to pair her with a Producer who'd probably guarantee a hit. The same situation as hiring Stock/Aitken/Waterman to Produce Kylie, or Donna, or The Three Degrees, or Divine, or Boney M, or Jackie Quartz, or...or...(I think you get the idea)

    Unfortunately, by 1979 Alec's creative diversity (within the Disco genre), was on the wane (think "John & Arthur Simms", The Midnight Band", Phil & The Blanks", or "Bad News Travels Fast", etc...), and he and Khnenetsky just couldn't come up with material that sparked any interest.

    It's also quite possible that Khnenetsky did most of it and Alec rubber-stamped it as Producer, like he did for Ray Jimenez, with the "Alirol & Jaquet" LP. (Or, as Moroder did with Bob Esty's Productions of "Once Upon A Time" and "Gettin' The Spirit".)

    I'm certain, had this LP produced a hit (and, honestly, a decent remix of the title track could have garnered it some respectable club play), there would have been more independent artists produced by Alec.

    Also, take into account that (as I was told by a friend of Alec's), by 1980 Alec was tiring of the whole Recording business grind. Keep in mind, that he was really a Pop-music writer, first. And was never truly comfortable within the confines of the "Disco Producer" tag*** considering he'd been writing, recording and producing (with considerable success) for over a decade, prior to even "Love In C Minor".

    ***I distinctly recall 2 things about his late 70's appearance on the Mike Douglas Show (almost a required gig for any Casablanca act)...
    First: He corrected Douglas, upon being called Alex Costandinos...
    "My name is ALEC"
    Second: He corrected Douglas' question (in reference to "Romeo & Juliet" and "Love & Kisses"), regarding "making Disco records"...
    "My recordings are not DISCO records..." (and I agree...to refer to "Judas", "Romeo & Juliet", or "Sumeria", his 3 most recent recordings at the time of the interview, simply as "Disco" is a bit of a diminution.)

    POSTSCRIPT: I KNEW we'd covered most of this recently...
    http://www.discomusic.com/forums/dis...ent-disco.html
    "MUSIC IS AN EMOTION, SEARCHING FOR IT'S VOICE"

    ...come with me, "BACK TO MUSIC", on DISCOTERIA
    http://www.live365.com/stations/cdnbob2

  20. #20
    Joined
    Jun 2002
    Location
    Toronto
    Posts
    365

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Quote Originally Written by SandraDee View Post
    I found the George Mcrae LP produced by Gregg Diamond disappointing. The Phyllis Hyman material that Narada Michael Walden produced was naff too (& I love both of them so much). The Carol Douglas LP that Greg Carmichael & Fitch/Cross shared production credits on (Come Into My Life) was a let down for me too. I have to say that I'm a huge Nile Rodgers fan generally but his 80s collaborations with Grace Jones, David Bowie & Madonna all left me rather cold.
    Hey SD, I would have a 2nd listen to "Love In Motion"....love that song and it might entice you to give it a second chance..

    V

  21. #21
    remicks's Avatar
    remicks is online now Double Platinum Record [Level 9]
    Joined
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Central Coast California
    Posts
    5,366

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Quote Originally Written by STEPHEN L FREEMAN View Post
    Probably the way most studio pairings tend to occur...

    Alec was on top as a Producer (or at least, had been, for a couple years) and Tina's label wanted to pair her with a Producer who'd probably guarantee a hit. The same situation as hiring Stock/Aitken/Waterman to Produce Kylie, or Donna, or The Three Degrees, or Divine, or Boney M, or Jackie Quartz, or...or...(I think you get the idea)
    Yes, I get the idea , but I'm trying to imagine the scenario a little beyond that. Even in the examples you list .... there has to be a degree of a story within each of them ....besides SAW's track record. And unlike SAW, Costandinos didn't have an ongoing history of working around vocal acts , creating hits for them ....

    This is to be Tina's second LP for United Artists...after her first for them fell flat. Someone there must have thought ...we need to hook Miss Turner up with someone really contemporary ....someone who can deliver in today's market . But even at that, its hard to fathom their coming up with "that guy over at Casablanca that does those epic disco productions" as their solution ... as the producer who could probably guarantee them a hit :icon_eek:

    And I certainly can't imagine Tina Turner saying, "You know what I'm really into now? --- disco . In fact for this album, how about we try to get that cat that did that nice and rough THANK GOD ITS FRIDAY song?" -

    ... Now, thinking about it from Alec's side ....perhaps he had put the word out that he wanted to try his hand at producing a name. Maybe he felt ready to expand beyond his anonymous projects. Maybe he even had a personal interest in working with Tina Turner specifically . ... maybe ...

    Who knows how it came about .... Well , they each do ... I sure would've liked to have been a fly on the wall when these two got together for this ..



    ***I distinctly recall 2 things about his late 70's appearance on the Mike Douglas Show (almost a required gig for any Casablanca act)...
    First: He corrected Douglas, upon being called Alex Costandinos...
    "My name is ALEC"
    Second: He corrected Douglas' question (in reference to "Romeo & Juliet" and "Love & Kisses"), regarding "making Disco records"...
    "My recordings are not DISCO records..." (and I agree...to refer to "Judas", "Romeo & Juliet", or "Sumeria", his 3 most recent recordings at the time of the interview, simply as "Disco" is a bit of a diminution.)
    Hmmmm.... my ain't he just a bit of an ingrate . If he didn't want to be associated with disco, then "put your hand over your mouth when you cough , that'll help the solution" .....to quote Mavis .....OR ....better yet consider this short list of career "don'ts" :

    1) Don't release your recordings under the mega-disco label Casablanca ... the one that ships your promos alongside those by Donna Summer and The Village People to record pools.

    2) Don't contribute to or write the title songs to any movies about disco.

    and most importantly :

    3) Don't underscore your compositions with an incessant thump-thump-thump.





    *****

    :icon_question: ... er .... Jackie Quartz? :icon_question: :icon_redface:
    Last edited by remicks; December 29th, 2008 at 10:23 AM.
    Baby, take me
    high upon a hillside

    high up where the stallion
    meets the sun



  22. #22
    Joined
    Aug 2004
    Location
    Seattle, WA - USA
    Posts
    639

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Quote Originally Written by STEPHEN L FREEMAN View Post
    I dunno... Her remake of Katia's "Party Lights" did pretty well for me. Of course, I had to use the DiscoNet extended edit, as there was no 12" mix. But it's an excellent restructuring of one of my favorite France Joli tracks.

    And to quote KDavid13's write-up on the LP, on the Disco-Discography side of DiscoMusic.com; "PARTY LIGHTS also won the "Most outstanding performance award" at the World Popular Song Festival in Tokyo (1984)"
    Evidently that song festival wasn't popular in the rest of the world.

    I liked Party Lights. And the title track. But the Witch Of Love lp had a thin sound to it, especially compared to George Duke's other productions. Like he recorded a demo on a 4-track, and Epic released it as is.
    "Because there's music in the air."

  23. #23
    Joined
    Feb 2004
    Location
    Freehold, New Jersey
    Posts
    591

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?

    Quote Originally Written by STEPHEN L FREEMAN View Post
    ***I distinctly recall 2 things about his late 70's appearance on the Mike Douglas Show (almost a required gig for any Casablanca act)...
    First: He corrected Douglas, upon being called Alex Costandinos...
    "My name is ALEC"
    Second: He corrected Douglas' question (in reference to "Romeo & Juliet" and "Love & Kisses"), regarding "making Disco records"...
    "My recordings are not DISCO records..." (and I agree...to refer to "Judas", "Romeo & Juliet", or "Sumeria", his 3 most recent recordings at the time of the interview, simply as "Disco" is a bit of a diminution.)
    You have to sometimes wonder if "disco artists" truly loved being associated with the genre they helped make strong contributions to. A long time ago, I remember reading either a Donna or Gloria interview and (paraphrasing here) she said something like, "I'm not a disco artist. I'm an artist who sings to disco music."
    "Everyone knows the real reason why you got that part it was the time you spent on that casting couch"--Antoine Merriwether
    "Excuse me, Miss Thing, but both of us spent time on that couch"--Blaine Edwards

  24. #24
    Joined
    Aug 2003
    Location
    Victoria BC/Montreal QC
    Posts
    346

    Re: When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ?


     

     

    Quote Originally Written by Boogie Child View Post
    Giorgio Moroder:

    France Joli "Attitude" LP
    Janet Jackson "Dream Street" LP

    Moroder had nothing to do with Attitude (though he got an Exec Producer credit). It was all Pete Belotte.

    As for Janet, she wasn't really a giant back then though Moroder has said he wished he realized she had more talent and had given her better material (he said all he saw was this scared girl who was forced to sing every note by her father).

    While I actually really like the album I think most would put Costandinos' album for Tina Turner--Love Explosion here.

Similar Threads

  1. Giants
    By InvisibleMan in Disco Dance Music, Artists, DJs and History
    Replies: 1
    Last Entry: November 23rd, 2009, 04:38 AM
  2. When Giants Take On Giants , You Get ...... Duds ? --- Not Always
    By remicks in Disco Dance Music, Artists, DJs and History
    Replies: 1
    Last Entry: April 13th, 2008, 10:46 AM
  3. The GIANTS 45 from AVI Records
    By Marcio** in Disco Dance Music, Artists, DJs and History
    Replies: 2
    Last Entry: February 23rd, 2004, 11:06 AM
  4. Two giants cross paths (hey, this is a QUIZ)
    By Nano in Disco Dance Music, Artists, DJs and History
    Replies: 9
    Last Entry: November 20th, 2003, 01:52 PM

Bookmarks

Permissions

  • You may not Start New Discussions
  • You may not add a reply
  • You may not add attachments
  • You may not edit your entries
  •