American Idol

[keefelc]

Was it just me or did anyone else find the comments made by Randy, Paula and Olivia Newton-John really boring and unoriginal, particularly when compared to the comments by Gladys Knight from last week? Even Simon seemed tired and lacklustered. Olivia came off as an airhead to me. Maybe too much Academy Awards partying over the weekend??? :-?

[Outsider]

Julia was ousted last night, right? I'm surprised it look this long. :evil:

[nrgbeat]

Read about the latest "American Idol" scandal involving Corey Clark at this link.

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/doc_o_day/doc_o_day.shtml

[Outsider]

Well, the song theme last night was indeed disco, which should interest everyone here. However, I didn't think that any of the remaining contestants were any good at it, especially Joshua. It looks like the war may not be the only thing standing between him and winning the competition. Let's put it this way: He's definitely not a disco singer. Neither are the others. But I think that Joshua's days on this show have come to an end.

I noticed that there was a contestant missing. Weren't there supposed to be nine left? I only counted eight. :evil:

[nrgbeat]

Corey Clark was booted off the show for not revealing an arrest record.

[HustleBaby]

He may be a United States marine but Joshua gots to go!!!!!!! He's still in the race because no one wants to axe the marine but his performance on tuesday STUNK!!

The next one to go is Carmen "Turn The Beat Around" or Kimberly "Knock On Wood". I think that they remain in the race because they can work the stage and their looks. Honestly, Carmen gots to go!!!!!!

How can anyone not vote for Kimberly Locke?????? :o :o I can't believe that she (out of three) had the lowest votes???
When she sung "It's Raining Men", she sounded just like Martha Warsh! Out of all the girls, she's my favorite.

Now when it comes to the guys, I'm torn between Reuben, white guy with the BIG voice and the other black guy who hits those high-pitch notes.

Simon Cunt didn't like anyone's performance but Reuben, maybe he dosen't like disco :-? Ah the hell with him!

*DELIGHTFUL*

[Outsider]

I can't believe that nobody got axed this week. So what if Corey was booted off for not revealing his arrest record? The show still has go on as planned, which is that each week one contestant has their last dance. The reason that nobody's a goner this week is because the show has to run on a schedule, and also more weeks means more sponsorship money. I know it will be the same if Joshua gets called up for duty. It looks like we'll see "more, more, more" of all the remaining contestants. :evil:

[nrgbeat]

My three choices for this week would have been:

Joshua Gracin--disco just ain't his thang.

Rickey Smith

Carmen

[markydefad]

Judging from last night's performances, I'd say Carmen should get the ole boot tonight....but, it's kinda hard to predict, I've learned. (Interestingly, Miss Carmen was the only performer to do an upbeat tune--Blondie's "Call Me"; she was roundly criticized.)

The song choices last night were pretty boring and obvious. They had to sing a #1 Billboard hit, so they had at least 40+ years of material to choose from. They mostly covered treacly power-ballads like "My Heart Will Go On" and "Endless Love."

I think Simon/Simone took his Zoloft this week. She was remarkably chipper and upbeat; very unlike her depressed Disco show self. Wut up wit dat?????

[Outsider]

I missed last night's episode, so I can't comment on the show this week. But since I read that the theme last night was songs that reached #1 on the Billboard charts, I was wondering if anyone sang a Beatles song. They certainly had plenty of them (27 to be exact). But I'm guessing that none of them did. :evil:

[nrgbeat]

My pic to get booted tonight is Carmen.

[Outsider]

Originally Posted by nrgbeat

My pic to get booted tonight is Carmen.

I have to agree with you. From what I saw, she gave by far the worst performance of the night. She'll be getting taken out of the game tonight.

And since last night was Billy Joel night, why wasn't he the celebrity guest? Nothing wrong with Smokey Robinson, but having Billy there would have made a lot more sense. :evil:

[markydefad]

Well, Carmen certainly must be the Spawn of Satan!!!! Once again, she has eluded the proverbial "gong" and remains in the contest!!! Even chief-supporter Simon/Simone dished her performance this week!!! (Quite MEANLY, in fact.)

Speaking of which, next week's Entertainment Weekly supposedly has a cover story on "American Idol" calling it "The Gayest Show On TV"!!!!! The bitchy banter between Miss Ryan And Simon/Simone has prompted a lotta "it's SOOOOOO GAY" talk around water-coolers in America. Well, DUHHHHHHH!!!! I say.

I've heard Clay is of the gay persuasion, also. I wonder if Ryan had his stylist do Clay's makeover. Or maybe Ryan did it himself. She's one -talented little hair froster, I'm told. ("Daddy needs new highlights" was one of his choice lines last night).

I guess Ruben is in the catbird seat. It's his to lose at this point. I would guess Clay to be the runner-up. But then, I've been wrong before.

[Outsider]

I'm surprised it was the other blonde woman who was eliminated. Well, it proves that looks aren't everything. :evil:

[HustleBaby]

I am shocked that Carmen stayed and Kimberly was booted :x :evil: ! Carmen has been giving the worst performances over the past few weeks and I'm sick of her already. Maybe she has a rabbit's foot, a horseshoe, leprechaun, rosaries etc.....cause I can't see how in the hell she remains in the game :o :x ! Next week Carmen Can't Cut-It has to go!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :evil:

I've always favored Elton John over Billy Joel however BJ has several hits that won me over:

I Love You Just The Way You Are
Innocent Man
This Is The Time
New York State of Mind
Uptown Girl

*DISCO DELIGHT*